Unlike traditional fortune cookies that trade in hope, romance, and vague promises of adventure, this one feels refreshingly honest. There’s no sugarcoating and no mystery, just the quiet perspective of a cat that already knows how this all ends. And that’s why the Blame It on the Dog Fortune Cookie Cat Toy from Modern Beast works so well.
At first glance, it looks like a tiny felt fortune cookie you’d expect to crack open at the end of takeout night. The difference is that this one isn’t pretending your future is full of surprises. It’s designed for cats, filled with organic catnip, and paired with fortune-style sayings that read more like observations than predictions. The kind that makes you pause, reread, and admit that, yes, this tracks.
The design is simple in a way that feels intentional. Soft felt, neutral tones, nothing flashy or loud. It doesn’t scream pet toy, which is probably why it feels dangerously close to becoming decor. If you’ve ever justified a pet purchase because it fit the vibe of your space, this will feel familiar. Some toys are meant to be shredded immediately. Others quietly sit on shelves, waiting for their moment. This one could easily do both.
The humor is subtle, and that’s what makes it land. Instead of trying to be over-the-top, the toy leans into the reality of living with cats. The fortune-style tags don’t promise good luck or exciting journeys. They acknowledge what any cat owner already knows. That your couch is temporary, that chaos is scheduled, that accountability is optional, especially if there’s a dog nearby.
Related: 10 Houseplants Safe for Cats and Dogs (With Pictures)
Blame It on the Dog Fortune Cookie Cat Toy, $12 at Modern Beasts
Modern Beasts
Of course, it’s not just a visual joke. The organic catnip inside gives it real play value, especially for cats who love batting, kicking, or carrying toys around like they’re important artifacts. It’s lightweight, easy to toss, and satisfying enough to hold a cat’s attention without feeling overstimulating.
Modern Beast has built a reputation around this kind of design. Their products tend to balance humor with restraint, creating items that feel thoughtful rather than gimmicky. This fortune cookie fits neatly into that lane. It doesn’t try to reinvent the wheel. It just delivers a small, clever idea and lets it speak for itself.
At $12, it’s also firmly in that category of purchases you don’t overthink. It’s a small gift, an easy add-on, or something you grab simply because it made you laugh. And honestly, that’s reason enough.
It doesn’t predict your future so much as confirm it. Because in a cat’s world, the order of events is simple. They nap. You serve. And somehow, you’re still being judged.
Related: This Extra-Large Litter Box Is a Game Changer for Big Cats Who Hate Small Spaces
This story was originally published by PetHelpful on Dec 23, 2025, where it first appeared in the Shopping section. Add PetHelpful as a Preferred Source by clicking here.