Pet toys are not just about function anymore. Many dog owners are choosing products that reflect their own interests, whether that means themed designs or items that feel familiar. Nostalgic products have become especially popular, as they connect everyday purchases to memories people already have. This shift has made novelty dog toys more appealing than standard options.
Retro-inspired dog toys, especially those tied to well-known franchises, offer a mix of play and personality. They give dogs something soft and engaging while also giving owners something recognizable and fun. For shoppers seeking something different from traditional plush toys, these designs offer a sense of familiarity that stands out on shelves.
🐶🐱🐶 SIGN UP to get “pawsitivity” delivered right to your inbox with inspiring & entertaining stories about our furry & feathered friends🐾🐾
Disney Beauty and the Beast VHS Dog Plush Toy, $5 at Popshelf
This plush toy is designed to resemble a classic VHS tape of Beauty and the Beast. The rectangular shape makes it easy for dogs to carry, while the soft fabric keeps it comfortable for play.
Disney The Lion King VHS Dog Plush Toy, $5 at Popshelf
The Lion Kingversion follows the same retro design, giving pet owners a recognizable throwback. It works well as a light play toy or a comfort item for dogs that enjoy softer textures.
Related: This Shampoo Dispensing Dog Brush Makes Bath Time Easier
Disney The Little Mermaid VHS Dog Plush Toy, $5 at Popshelf
This design brings The Little Mermaid into the same VHS-style format. It adds variety for pet owners who want to choose a favorite film while still keeping a consistent toy style.
All three options are priced accessibly, making it easy to pick up more than one. While they are best suited for light to moderate play, they can still hold up well with regular use. They also work well as gifts. For pet owners who enjoy Disney or retro designs, these toys offer something a little more personal than standard plush toys.
If you enjoy unique pet finds, you might also like this custom pet sweater or this jumbo plush dog toy that is getting attention from shoppers.
Related: Hobby Lobby Is Selling a Sweet DIY Stepping Stone to Celebrate Your Dog
This story was originally published by PawNation on Mar 18, 2026, where it first appeared in the Pet Products section. Add PawNation as a Preferred Source by clicking here.