I never thought I would see the day when a dog toy could pass as a pantry essential, but here we are. Chewy’s San Muttzano Tomatoes Dog Toy looks so realistic that your dog might actually start believing they have entered their Italian chef era. The commitment to the bit is unreal, and the internet clearly agrees because this toy is blowing up everywhere.
Every year, dog toys somehow get more dramatic, more unexpected, and, honestly, more creative than anything being made for humans. This one is no exception. The second you see it, your brain goes, Wait, is that an actual can of peeled tomatoes? And then you realize it squeaks, it’s plush, and it contains three little tomato balls, and suddenly you’re laughing because it’s so ridiculously perfect.
The set includes a plush tomato can with a crinkly texture and three squeaker tomato balls. The design is so spot on that if you left it in your kitchen, someone would absolutely think you bought new groceries. The bright label, the faux metal top, the silly tomato graphics, all of it is giving full grocery store aisle energy. And the tomatoes themselves squeak, which is exactly the kind of unhinged detail dogs go feral for.
Bark San Muttzano Tomatoes Squeaky Ball Plush Dog Toy, $12.99 at Chewy
Shop It!
What makes this toy even better is its innovative design. The tomatoes act as little fetch balls, so you basically get several toys in one. You can hide treats inside the can and make it a puzzle toy, toss the tomatoes around for a quick game, or let your dog dig them out for some enrichment. It looks like a joke, but the versatility is genuinely impressive.
Related: Chewy’s 69-Inch Christmas Cat Tree Is the Festive Multilevel Tower Cats Are Obsessed With
Chewy shoppers are obsessed. The reviews are full of people saying their dogs immediately claimed the tomatoes and dragged the entire can around the house, as if they were running a restaurant. And because Bark makes it, the quality backs up the vibe. They specialize in turning everyday objects into ridiculous dog toys that dogs actually bond with.
If your dog loves toys with personality, squeaky chaos, or anything that looks like it belongs in a pantry rather than a toy bin, the San Muttzano Tomato set is a must. It’s funny, it’s functional, and it’s easily the next viral prop starring in your pet’s camera roll.
Related: Chewy’s Whimsical Cat Tunnel Is Purr-fect for Hyper Kitties
This story was originally published by PetHelpful on Dec 9, 2025, where it first appeared in the Shopping section. Add PetHelpful as a Preferred Source by clicking here.